SEC Chair Gary Gensler grilled by US House Committee over crypto, called ‘Tonya Harding of Regulation’.

SEC Chair Gary Gensler grilled by US House Committee over crypto, called 'Tonya Harding of Regulation'.

The Contentious Relationship Between Regulators and the Blockchain Industry

Source: Youtube / Yahoo Finance

In a congressional hearing on September 27, Gary Gensler, the chair of the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), found himself at the center of a heated debate regarding the oversight of crypto markets. The colorful analogies and sharp criticisms hurled at Gensler shed light on the contentious relationship between regulators and the blockchain industry.

“Tonya Harding of Regulations”

During the hearing, United States Representative Andy Barr made a memorable comparison, dubbing Gensler the “Tonya Harding of securities regulations.” Barr accused Gensler of burdening the U.S. capital markets with excessive regulatory red tape. He referred to Gensler’s previous assertion that the U.S. capital market should keep evolving and not rest on its laurels.

Barr’s analogy drew a connection to the infamous Tonya Harding-Nancy Kerrigan scandal, where Harding was involved in an attack on her figure skating rival. This comparison further exemplified the perception that Gensler’s approach to regulations was seen as aggressive and potentially damaging to the industry.

Representative Warren Davidson also expressed his dissatisfaction with Gensler, expressing hope that the Biden administration would dismiss him from his position. Davidson accused Gensler of advancing a “woke” political and social agenda and abusing his role as SEC Chair. He even suggested that the SEC Stabilization Act, introduced by him and Representative Tom Emmer, could facilitate Gensler’s removal.

Regulatory Status of Bitcoin

One of the key points of discussion during the hearing was the regulatory status of Bitcoin. Gensler faced questions from the U.S. House Committee on Financial Services Chair Patrick McHenry regarding this matter. In response, Gensler indicated that Bitcoin did not meet the criteria established by the Howey Test, implying that it is not considered a security.

However, when McHenry suggested that Bitcoin might be classified as a commodity, Gensler refrained from providing a definitive answer. He explained that the determination of whether Bitcoin is a commodity falls outside the scope of U.S. securities laws.

To add an unexpected twist to the hearing, U.S. Representative Ritchie Torres probed Gensler about the classification of physical Pokemon trading cards. Torres sought to understand whether purchasing these cards constituted a securities transaction. Gensler responded cautiously, stating that it depended on the context. He emphasized that the core of the Howey Test is whether the investing public anticipates profits based on the efforts of others.

This exchange highlighted the complexity of determining regulatory classifications for emerging assets and the need for clear guidelines to avoid confusion and potential legal issues.

Recently, the SEC has filed lawsuits against NFT issuers for not adhering to security laws, further illustrating the challenges in navigating the regulatory landscape of the blockchain industry.

“Stand With Crypto” Logo Displayed in the Background

As the hearing unfolded, keen observers noticed a Coinbase “Stand With Crypto” logo in the background—a nod to a Coinbase-led initiative advocating for cryptocurrency legislation in the United States. This campaign aims to promote cryptocurrency innovation and policy reform, and a notable event called “Stand With Crypto Day” recently took place in Washington, D.C.

While Gensler faced sharp criticism and analogies during the hearing, the future of cryptocurrency regulation remains a topic of debate and discussion among lawmakers and industry participants. The contentious relationship between regulators and the blockchain industry highlights the need for a balanced approach to ensure both investor protection and continued innovation in this rapidly evolving field.

Summary Table

Key Points
– The congressional hearing featuring SEC Chair Gary Gensler showcased the contentious relationship between regulators and the blockchain industry.
– Representative Andy Barr compared Gensler to “Tonya Harding of securities regulations,” criticizing his approach to regulatory enforcement.
– Representative Warren Davidson expressed his hope for Gensler’s dismissal, accusing him of advancing a “woke” political and social agenda.
– Gensler indicated that Bitcoin did not meet the criteria of the Howey Test, suggesting it is not considered a security. However, its classification as a commodity remained uncertain.
– The questioning also included a discussion on the classification of physical Pokemon trading cards, highlighting the complexity of defining securities transactions.
– The SEC’s recent lawsuits against NFT issuers demonstrate the challenges in navigating regulatory compliance.
– The presence of a “Stand With Crypto” logo in the background underscored the ongoing effort to advocate for cryptocurrency legislation.
– The debate surrounding cryptocurrency regulation continues, emphasizing the need for a balanced approach to foster investor protection and innovation.

We will continue to update Phone&Auto; if you have any questions or suggestions, please contact us!


Was this article helpful?

93 out of 132 found this helpful

Discover more


Hold On to Your Yo-Yo: Bitcoin Takes a Spin on the Playground with Limited Edition Duncan Butterfly XT

Introducing the highly-anticipated Limited Edition Bitcoin-themed Duncan Butterfly XT Yo-yo, designed to delight enth...


🚀 Is Bitcoin in the Early Stages of a Bull Market? 📈

According to Glassnode's on-chain analysis, Bitcoin has entered the high risk zone, a characteristic of the initial p...


Biting the Bullet: What Can We Expect After the Bitcoin ETF Approvals?

Despite a recent decline, Bitcoin continues to show resilience and potential for growth in the market. Following the ...


Ledger announces integration with U.S. PayPal, allowing in-app purchase of crypto.

PayPal joins a growing roster of services seamlessly integrated with Ledger Live, including MoonPay, Simplex, Transak...


What innovations does derivative DEX ApolloX V2 bring from a market share of 10% to 73% in one month?

Using the LP+ synthetic asset + oracle tracking asset price model, ApolloX has the ability to launch more long-tail a...


Ripple's $770M Disgorgement A Rocky Road Ahead for XRP Holders, Says Attorney

Fashionista According to lawyer John Deaton, it seems unlikely that Ripple will have to pay a $770 million fine in th...