Hermès wins request to stop ‘MetaBirkin’ NFT sales.

The luxury fashion brand Hermès has won another victory in its infringement case against artist Mason Rothschild, with a United States judge ordering a permanent injunction on all sales of “MetaBirkin” non-fungible tokens (NFTs).

Hermès first submitted the request to the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York in March to block all sales of the MetaBirkin NFTs.

On June 23, Manhattan-based U.S. Judge Jed Rakoff granted the request and expressed skepticism about Rothschild’s defense against Hermès’ suit, questioning Rothschild’s continued marketing of the project.

“[The] defendant’s entire scheme here was to defraud consumers into believing, by his use of variations on Hermes’ trademarks, that Hermes was endorsing his lucrative MetaBirkins NFTs,” Rakoff said, adding that:

“Nothing in the First Amendment insulates him from liability for such a scheme.”

The MetaBirkin collection consists of 100 NFT artworks depicting furry Birkin-style handbags, with Rothschild reportedly generating more than $1 million worth of sales from the project.

MetaBirkins 78 just sold for 2.3 Ether (≈$4,000) to @wyaricky on @LooksRareNFT! pic.twitter.com/8RPLukg8WY

— MetaBirkins (@MetaBirkins) September 12, 2022

The legal dispute began in January after Hermès accused Rothschild’s NFT collection of improperly using its Birkin trademark, leading customers to believe the brand was supporting the project.

In February, the court ruled that Rothschild had violated Hermès trademark following a nine-member jury verdict, with the artist ordered to pay $133,000 in damages.

Rothschild had argued that his project was an artistic expression protected by the First Amendment, in a similar vein that enabled Andy Warhol to legally make and sell art featuring Campbell’s soup cans.

Take nine people off the street right now and ask them to tell you what art is but the kicker is whatever they say will now become the undisputed truth. That’s what happened today. A multibillion dollar luxury fashion house who says they “care” about art and artists but..

— Mason Rothschild (@MasonRothschild) February 8, 2023

Additionally, the artist asserted that he hadn’t explicitly misled consumers, as he had provided disclaimers explaining that Hermès had no affiliation.

Related: German intelligence service launched dog-themed NFTs to fetch cyber talent

However, the judge and jury also refuted this, as the use of the word “Birkins” was brought into question.

“The jury found that his decision to use Hermès’ trademarks in the name and design of the MetaBirkins NFTs — not just his marketing and sales techniques — was explicitly misleading and rejected his disclaimer defense,” the court doc reads.

Magazine: NFT Creator: ‘Holy shit, I’ve seen that!’ — Coldie’s Snoop Dogg, Vitalik and McAfee NFTs

We will continue to update Phone&Auto; if you have any questions or suggestions, please contact us!

Share:

Was this article helpful?

93 out of 132 found this helpful

Discover more

Policy

The Financial Stability Board’s Plans for Crypto, Tokenization, and AI in 2024

The Financial Stability Board is set to release a comprehensive update on its crypto roadmap, including a report on t...

NFT

Digital fashion brand to release NFT patches linked to real-world rewards.

This collection of patches showcases the incredible talent of 11 renowned artists, such as Jen Stark, the creative mi...

Policy

Title: EU Approves Stricter Sanctions Rules for Crypto: Frozen Assets Confiscated and Loopholes Closed! 🛑💰

The implementation of laws ensures that sanctions regulations are consistently enforced throughout all 27 member stat...

NFT

How are NFT transaction income taxed in Canada? What are the legal risks of not paying taxes?

This article examines the basic principles of taxing NFTs in Canada's cryptocurrency taxation system; the methods use...

Policy

Softer deal on crypto influencer law in France

The last agreement seems to permit crypto firms that are registered to promote their products through social media in...

Opinion

Social Chain Game Gas Hero The sequel after StepN, can it carry the future of the GMT ecosystem?

The game background of Gas Hero tells the story of a post-apocalyptic world where surviving humans, after a nuclear w...